Sarah (Bryan) Astwood
Privacy Level: Open (White)

Sarah (Bryan) Astwood (abt. 1602 - bef. 1669)

Sarah Astwood formerly Bryan aka Baldwin
Born about in Englandmap
Daughter of [father unknown] and [mother unknown]
[sibling(s) unknown]
Wife of — married 1620 in Aston Clinton, Buckinghamshire, Englandmap
Wife of — married 1640 in Milford, New Haven, Connecticutmap
Descendants descendants
Died before before about age 67 in Milford, New Haven, Connecticut Colonymap
Profile last modified | Created 14 Sep 2010
This page has been accessed 4,803 times.
The Puritan Great Migration.
Sarah (Bryan) Astwood migrated to New England during the Puritan Great Migration (1621-1640).
Join: Puritan Great Migration Project
Discuss: pgm

Contents

Disputed Origins

Citing R. C. Anderson's "The Great Migration" and "The Ancestry and Descendants of Frederick Tracy Camp & his wife" (Ed Jacobus); the *parents* attached to this profile are being detached - Thomas Bryan and Francis (Bowlinge) Bryan since there are not even secondary sources which rely on anything but supposition or proximity.[1][2]Also the unsourced exact birth date and place "August 25, 1602 at Aylesbury, Buckinghamshire, England are being generalized.

Biography

Sarah Bryant/Bryan, born approximately 1602 may have been the daughter of Thomas Bryan and Frances Bowlinge; who were probably relatives of Alexander Bryant/Bryan[3]but parentage is not proven.[2]

She emigrated with her 1st husband Sylvester Baldwin, son of Sylvester and grandson of Henry Baldwin of Dundridge; Aston Clinton, co., Bucks, England; and their 6 surviving children (according to CC Baldwin's summation of Mr Savage's account of the will of Sylvester Baldwin;, which original has been lost); on the ship "Martin" in 1638[4]

They were original settlers of Milford.[5]

Sylvester Baldwin Jr., died in June of 1638 at sea; his nuncupative will dated June 21,1638 and proved 13 July 1638, in the Court of Assistants, held in Boston, July of 1638; naming his wife and son Richard executors.[4]According to CC Baldwin, the following account of the will of Silvester Bauldwin; was had by Hon. James Savage as follows:

At a Court of Assistants, held in Boston, July or Sept 4, 1638; "The will of Silvester Bauldwin was p'sented unto the Court, and his wife Sarah and sonne Rich'd were allowed executors according to the will"[6]
On the main ocean, bound for N.E., his nuncupative will was made 21 June and proved 13 July, of that year, before the Dept. Gov. (name illegible); by oaths of Chad Brown, Francis Bolt, James Weeden, and John Baldwin. The estate was good and provision liberal for the six children, as well as the widow, to whom, with son Richard, our general court, 4 Sept. following, committed the administration[7]

Children of Sylvester Baldwin Jr. and Sarah Bryant

All baptized in Aston Clinton, Bucks co., England[4]

  1. Sarah, bapt. April 22, 1621; m. Hon. Benjamin Fenn, of Milford Ct.
  2. Richard, 25 Aug 1622 {Richard of Milford}
  3. Mary (1), Feb 28 1624; buried Nov 3, 1625
  4. Mary (2), Feb 19, 1626; m. (1) Robert Plum of Milford, Ct., and (2) William East of the same place
  5. Martha, April 20, 1628; prob. died unmarried
  6. Samuel, July 1, 1632; buried Jan 4, 1633
  7. Elizabeth, Jan 28, 1634, buried 3 days later
  8. John, Oct 28, 1635 {John of Stonington}
  9. Ruth, is shown on Baldwin Genealogy [4] but nothing further; and in Chester's Investigations Pg 16, Ruth is not shown at all.

In CC Baldwins Supplement published in 1889; to his original published book in 1881; he says "Ruth appears in Sylvester's nuncuptative will, but not in that of her mother, probably dying young[8]

The Reported Surviving Children of Sylvester Baldwin and Sarah Bryant

According to Hon. James Savage's account of the nuncupative will dated June 21, 1638; proved July 13, 1638 (Boston Court)

  1. Richard
  2. Sarah
  3. Mary
  4. Martha
  5. Ruth
  6. John

The widow Sarah (Bryant/Bryan) Baldwin, and her 6 surviving children, followed the other emigrants to New Haven and was the widow Baldwin enrolled among the first planters there, five in her family[9] (Sarah the oldest, probably had married by then to Benjamin Fenn [10]and no longer among those counted; nothing is further heard of Ruth)

She was given a lot in the southwest square or Hertfordshire quarter of New Haven which is now located at the corner of Chapel and York streets in New Haven[citation needed]

Note

It seems Sarah Bryant, a widow in 1638; who emigrated with her husband and 6 children found herself in New Haven, with most likely 4 children (Richard, Mary, Martha, John), with Sarah the oldest, married now, and Ruth mentioned in her fathers will in 1638; probably died shortly after.

The fifth child included in the count of Sarah (Bryant) Baldwin, widow, now in New Haven, enrolled as a planter five in her family;[9] may have been John Baldwin of Norwich, relative to Sylvester; possibly traveling with this family as was tradition; and may have been the John Baldwin who witnessed the nuncupative will of Sylvester in 1638; Sylvester's own son, John was only 3 yrs old in 1638.

2nd Marriage and death

Sarah (Bryant) Baldwin, widow of Sylvester, married (2) by August 2, 1640, to Capt. John Astwood, of Milford, Ct.,[5] [11]

John Astwood died in London between June 27, 1654 (date of will) and August 31, 1654 (probate of will)[1]as Agent of the Colony.

She died in November of 1669 and was buried in Milford on November 13, 1669;[1]Her will was dated Nov 9, 1669, and proved the 20th[12]No known children from this marriage.[1]

Will of Sarah Bryant/Bryan-Baldwin-Astwood

Dated 9 November 1669[13]

Bequeathes to daughter Mary (Baldwin) Plumb, wife of Robert Plumb, most of her goods and chattels as well as a book called " The Soule's Conflict".
She mentions grandchildren:
John Baldwin (son of John)
Mary Woodruff and her husband Matthew Woodruff (dau of Mary Plumb)
Silvanus Baldwin (son of Richard)
Sarah Riggs (dau of Richard)
Temperance Baldwin (dau of Richard)
Mary Baldwin (dau of Richard)
Sarah Burwell (dau of Sarah Fenn)
Mehitable Fenn (wife of Benjamin , son of Sarah Fenn)
Martha Newton (dau of Sarah Fenn)
Hannah Freeman, wife of Stephen (daughter of John Astwood by his 1st marriage
She mentions:
Dau. Elizabeth Baldwin, (widow of Richard)
Son John Baldwin
Great Grand-children:
Matthew Woodruff (son of Mary Woodruff)
Sarah Burwell (dau of Sarah Burwell)
John Plumb (son of Mary Plumb)

Appointed brothers Richard Platt and Thomas Wheeler, to be overseers, and Mary Plumb, daughter, executor in New Haven County, Conn. (New Haven Probate Reel, Vol 1).[14]

Her inventory was taken on 20 November 1669.[13]

Sarah Astwood is buried at the Milford Cemetery, New Haven County, Conn[15]

Research Notes

Sarah Bryan is cited as sister of Alexander Bryan. [16]

Sarah Bryan

Birth 25 AUG 1602
Burial 13 NOV 1669 Milford, New Haven Co., CT
Note: From "The Ancestry and Descendants of Frederick Tracy Camp & his wife
Marion Fee," compiled by John F. Camp, Jr. and N. Grier Parke, II,
with the editorial help of Donald Lines Jacobus, p. 25: "It was stated
years ago that Sarah was a Bryant (Bryan?), but no evidence has ever
been put forward to sustain the assertion, nor has a place been found
for her among the connections of Alexander Bryan of Milford, whose
antecedents have been traced in England. Her will appointed 'my
beloved brothers' Richard Platt and Thomas Wheeler, to be overseers,
but Richard Platt was not her actual brother, and it has yet to be
proved that they were brothers-in-law of herself or of either her
first or her second husband. They were her brothers in the fellowship
of the church, and may have been highly respected friends in whom she
felt confidence." (authors' references: For discussion of the Platt
angle, see The American Genealogist, 31:160-2)
Spouses: Sylvester Baldwin (1600 - 1638)*
John Astwood (1609 - 1654)*
Children: John Baldwin (1619 - 1681)*
Sarah Baldwin Fenn (1621 - 1663)*
Richard Baldwin (1622 - 1665)*
Mary Baldwin Plumb (1626 - 1708)*
John Baldwin (1635 - 1683)*
Burial: Milford Cemetery, Milford, New Haven, Connecticut, USA
Plot: Buried in Rev. Peter Prudden's Garden
  • Immigration (July 1638) On the ship "Martin" New Haven, New Haven, Colony of Connecticut, British Colonial America
  • Will (9 November 1669) Milford, New Haven, Connecticut, United States
  • Burial (13 November 1669) Milford Cemetery, Milford, New Haven, Connecticut, United States
  • Probate (20 November 1669) Milford, New Haven, Connecticut, United States
  • http://familysearch.org/v1/LifeSketch The prestigious NEHGS "The Great Migration" dispels the notion of a maiden name of Bryan. It is the gold standard of all sources since it was prepared by the full staff and resources of the NEHGS. It incorporates and uses references from all verified publications. Those who use Bryan are not recognizing the evolution of research that has led to this conclusion. Not a single original source such as a will, birth record, child's birth record, deed, etc. gives the maiden name of Bryan. Original sources are needed and not speculation from second level publications if one insists on the surname Bryan.

Additional sources:

History of the Colony of New Haven: before and after the union of Connecticut : containing a particular description of the towns which composed that government, viz., New Haven, Milford, Guilford, Branford, Stamford, & Southold, L.I., with a notice of the towns which have been set off from "the original six". New Haven Conn.: Hitchcock & Stafford, 1838. Quite valuable since their compilation was submitted to the Library of Congress. The author cites the NEGHS publication often as his source of information.

Another publication: "Ye At Wode Annals" Another excellent book written by a scholar, an educator and a descendant of Sylvester Baldwin.

"Genealogical Notes on the Founding of the Colony of New England", page 249 or digital image 252. Discusses Sylvester Baldwin's family, parents, siblings, and life.

"History of the Colony of New Haven: before and after the union of Connecticut", the author's opening sentence "Authentic history if of high importance". Excellent publication.

Sources

  1. 1.0 1.1 1.2 1.3 Great Migration 1634-1635, A-B. (Online database. AmericanAncestors.org. New England Historic Genealogical Society, 2008.) Originally published as: The Great Migration, Immigrants to New England, 1634-1635, Volume 1, A-B, by Robert Charles Anderson, George F. Sanborn, Jr., and Melinde Lutz Sanborn. Boston: New England Historic Genealogical Society, 1999. p. 94.subscription
  2. 2.0 2.1 "Ancestry and Descendants of Frederick Tracy Camp & his wife Marion Fee"
  3. Genealogy Supplement; retrieved 2018-04-09 from rch/sylvester Pg 992
  4. 4.0 4.1 4.2 4.3 Pg 41 Baldwin genealogy from 1500-1881; retrieved 2018-04-09 https://archive.org/stream/baldwingenealogy00bald#page/41/mode/1up
  5. 5.0 5.1 Great Migration Newsletter, V.1-20.(Online Database: AmericanAncestors.org, New England Historic Genealogical Society, 2018.) Vol. 13, p. 14.subscriber$
  6. Mass Records, Vol 1, p. 23, marg. 226; as cited in CC Baldwins published book "Baldwin Genealogy from 1500-1881
  7. Pgs 41-42; Chesters "Baldwin Genealogy from 1500-1881
  8. Baldwin Genealogy pg 993
  9. 9.0 9.1 Pg 42 Baldwin genealogy
  10. Torrey’s New England Marriages Prior to 1700. (Online database. AmericanAncestors.org. New England Historic Genealogical Society, 2008.) Originally published as: New England Marriages Prior to 1700. Boston, Mass.: New England Historic Genealogical Society, 2015 Vol 1 p 535
  11. Baldwin, Charles. Alexander Bryan of Milford, Connecticut, His Ancestors and His Descendants (Leader Print. Co., Cleveland, Ohio, 1889) [https://archive.org/stream/alexanderbryanof00bald#page/11/mode/1up Page 14
  12. Pg 43 Baldwin genealogy 1500-1881
  13. 13.0 13.1 “New Haven Probate Records, Vol. 1-2, 1647-1703”, database with images, FamilySearch (https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:3QS7-L92K-G9NJ-6 : 8 March 2021), New Haven, Connecticut, FHL microfilm 007626739, image 158-159. New Haven Probate Record, 1647-1687, Vol. 1, Part 2, page 33-34.
  14. Pgs 43-44 Baldwin genealogy 1500-1881; retrieved 2018-04-09 from https://archive.org/stream/baldwingenealogy00bald#page/43/mode/1up
  15. Find A Grave, database and images (accessed 26 March 2019), memorial page for Sarah Bryan Astwood (1606–20 Nov 1669), Find A Grave: Memorial #28222832, citing Milford Cemetery, Milford, New Haven County, Connecticut, USA ; Maintained by Nareen, et al (contributor 46613568) .Gravestone picture
  16. Charles C. Baldwin, Notes on the Ancestry of Sylvester Baldwin online<https://sites.rootsweb.com/~ctcmilfo/SBaldwinNotes.htm> Previously published in hard copy (Boston: David Clapp & Son, 1872).
  • "Family Tree," database, FamilySearch (http://familysearch.org : modified 22 August 2019, 07:46), entry for Sarah(PID https://familysearch.org/ark:/61903/4:1:996H-WNF); contributed by various users.
  • "Family Tree," database, FamilySearch (http://familysearch.org : modified 06 February 2019, 02:24), entry for Sarah Bryan(PID https://familysearch.org/ark:/61903/4:1:GMZT-5MN); contributed by various users.
  • Baldwin, Charles Candee. The Baldwin Genealogy From 1500 To 1881|The Baldwin Genealogy From 1500 To 1881]](The Leader Printing Company, Cleveland, Ohio, 1881)
  • Baldwin, C.C. (1889)Baldwin Genealogy Supplement. Cleveland Leader Print, Cleveland, Ohio.
  • Investigations concerning the family of Baldwin, of Aston Clinton, Bucks by Chester, Joseph Lemuel, 1821-1882; Publication date 1884; Publisher Boston : D. Clapp & Son [Reprinted from the Historical and genealogical register for April, July and October, 1884]
  • "The Ancestry and Descendants of Frederick Tracy Camp & his wife Marion Fee", compiled by John F. Camp, Jr. and N. Grier Parke, II,; with the editorial help of Donald Lines Jacobus, p. 25
  • Wheeler, Richard. History of the Town of Stonington, County of New London, Connecticut (Day Publishing, Co., New London, Conn., 1900) Page 223
In 1643 "the Widow Baldwin" was recorded in New Haven as one of the wealthiest proprietors.




Sponsored Search by Ancestry.com

DNA
No known carriers of Sarah's DNA have taken a DNA test. Have you taken a test? If so, login to add it. If not, see our friends at Ancestry DNA.


Comments: 21

Leave a message for others who see this profile.
There are no comments yet.
Login to post a comment.
Please removed Baldwin-10008 Sarah Baldwin from this Bryan-33 profile. She is not the daughter of Sylvester Baldwin and Sarah (Bryan) Baldwin and there is no evidence for this association. This Sarah Baldwin married Alexander Edwards and lived in Springfield, Massachusetts. I have removed Baldwin-10008 from Sylvester Baldwin, but am unable to do so for Bryan-33 because Bryan-33 is PPP.

Sarah (Baldwin) Fenn IS the daughter of Sylvester and Sarah (Bryan) Fenn and there is evidence for this relationship as well as her marriage to Benjamin Fenn. Thank you!

posted by Carol Baldwin PhD RN
Hi Carol,

-1008 removed as child. Thank you for your research and improvements on this PGM profile.

Added source citing Sarah Bryan as sister of Alexander Bryan.
posted by Ellen Gustafson
unproven parents detached with notes & disputed origins. dob & pob generalized. 1st paragraph of bio updated.
The following was posted by E Logan, on the PGM project page but I'm transferring it here:

Is it OK if I go ahead and remove the parents for Sarah given there is no source for them being the parents at all?

Thanks,

Yes, it seems as though there is no source, E. Logan. If they are removed, please post again so this profile can be protected.

Ellen, a member of the PGM project agrees with you, below. But we've not heard from the profile managers in this discussion, and additional members of the PGM googlegroup have not responded.

Let's wait a day or two to allow others to post. If no one objects to the removal of parents, then proceed.

Objections to removal of parents?

Ok Cheryl. I’m ok with removing the parents.
posted by Ellen Gustafson
Requesting input/response from additional folks in the PGM internal googlegroup. Thank you.
Hi, "The Great Migration" doesn't seem to report on her surname at all, unless I missed something, I think we should be clear in saying that The Great Migration doesn't mention it at all - they didn't say they didn't find anything linking her to a Bryan.

I agree there's no evidence that her surname was "Bryan", but it seems inaccurate to me to say " Those who use Bryan are not recognizing the evolution of research that has led to this conclusion" - because it is stated in the context of the citation of the prestigious "The Great Migration", which does not comment on theories that her original surname was Bryan at all. I would suggest altering it to say something along the lines of:

"The prestigious 'The Great Migration' does not claim her maiden surname is Bryan/[t]"

and perhaps also move the citation of "The Ancestry and Descendants of Frederick Tracy Camp & his wife" to this spot as well, because that book DOES clear state that there is no primary evidence that her maiden surname was Bryan, while "The Great Migration" does not.

Secondly, "The Great Migration" states there was no date for the proof of her will, only that the inventory of her estate was taken on November 20th.

Mess of notes below

Re the "Alexander Bryan of Milford, Connecticut, his ancestors and his descendants" I'm having trouble wrapping my head around the wording, so once my printer is up and running again I'll have to sit down with a pen and highlighter to figure that out - but on p. 14 (15 in the archive.org counter), it states "In 1640, a company was formed, commanded by Capt. John Astwood, who in 1640 m. Sarah (Bryan) Baldwin, widow of Sylvester, ante p. 42" - unfortunately there is no p. 42 in this copy, so I'm a bit confused. The presumed relation to the Bryan family implied here is that Alexander Bryan is ensign of the company (this same Alexander Bryan is named earlier "The first merchants were Alexander Bryan, his son Richard, and William East. In 1640 "Ensign Bryan sent a vessel to the Bay '(Boston,)' laden with beaver, otter and other precious furs...") - this Alexander Bryan appears to be Bryan-181 (https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Bryan-181) in Wikitree.

posted by E. Logan
edited by E. Logan
The issue with this citation is that Alexander Bryan (Bryan-181) has no documented relationship to the alleged parents of this Sarah Astwood Baldwin - the book "Alexander Bryan of Milford, Connecticut, his ancestors and his descendants" denotes his father as Thomas Bryan (Bryan-846) and states:

"I traced Thomas no further back, but found entries which may be of interest to the name".

I'm not an expert on the Bryan family, however, so there could be other documents detailing a more detailed pedigree that shows how these two Bryan families are related.

In any case, the Bryan pages on this website are horrendously documented - people are incorrectly identified, sources that don't name the correct Bryan are cited as evidence for unsupported claims, etc.

posted by E. Logan
The only source for the surname Bryan/[t] seems to be this tidbit:

>He married Sarah , whose surname Hon John D. Baldwin, of Worcester, informed me long since, on the authority of Hon. Ralph D. Smith, of Guilford, Conn., was Bryant. Mr. Smith, a very high authority in early relationships of Connecticut, could not some years after, on my visiting him in Guilford, give me his authority. The fact, however, will appear very probable, as the English relationship and acquaintance of the Bryants was then unknown, having been afterwards discovered by myself.

from "Baldwin Genealogy from 1500-1881"

In any case, there is not even a single secondary source that reports her being the daughter of Thomas Bryan and Francis [1] - only secondary sources anecdotally report her as a Bryan tout court. On that basis, I propose we detach her from her current parents and remove the surname and relegate it to a section in her biography.

[1] I believe this comes from unsupported internet reports that claim Alexander Bryan (b. 1602), who is vaguely associated with Sarah, is the son of Thomas Bryan and Francis Bowling, when "Alexander Bryan of Milford, Connecticut, his ancestors and his descendants does not claim a Francis Bowling as the wife of Thomas Bryan of Aylesbury. Indeed, the reported parents and grandparents of this Sarah don't have ANY documentation AT ALL.

posted by E. Logan
edited by E. Logan
I would agree with the suggestions of E Logan as I don't currently see secondary sources which rely on anything but supposition or proximity. Suggest the detachment be made but that the profile link to the detached profiles with the statements citing Anderson and "The Ancestry and Descendants of Frederick Tracy Camp & his wife" (Ed Jacobus). This helps leave everything open in case research someday provides documentation or enough secondary evidence to require a fresh look.
posted by T Stanton
In the Charles Baldwin book you cite, the first few pages contain several examples of how the two families were acquainted and related. There is no documentation so far for either marriage other than the books cited. Perhaps a research note could state that her LNAB is uncertain.
posted by Ellen Gustafson
edited by Ellen Gustafson
I added another source for the second marriage. The same source mentions Richard Bryan, one of the first merchants in Milford, implying that he was a relative.
posted by Ellen Gustafson
edited by Ellen Gustafson
Hearing no response from my 2019 comment about her surname, I'm adding category "Needs Relationship Review" and will do some research, updating the profile in the near future.
I will also see what I can find on her.
posted by Ellen Gustafson
Great Ellen, thanks......................
If there is no scholarly source for the surname "Bryan," and it is "not proven" as stated in the biography, Sarah should probably have LNAB of "Unknown," with note of clarification in the biography. Thank you.

Since she migrated with her 1st husband, I'm going to add Puritan Great Migration Project Box. PGM will co-manage this profile, but please, will the current PMs continue managing as well? Thanks.

Children of Sylvester Baldwin and Anne Bryant/Bryan as shown in CC Baldwins original "Baldwin Genealogy from 1500-1881; pub 1881; and his supplement pub 1889:

1. Sarah, bapt. April 22, 1621; m. Hon. Benjamin Fenn, of Milford Ct. 2. Richard, 25 Aug 1622 {Richard of Milford} 3. Mary (1), Feb 28 1624; buried Nov 3, 1625 4. Mary (2), Feb 19, 1626; m. (1) Robert Plum of Milford, Ct., and (2) William East of the same place 5.Martha, April 20, 1628; prob. died unmarried 6.Samuel, July 1, 1632; buried Jan 4, 1633 7.Elizabeth, Jan 28, 1634, buried 3 days later 8.John, Oct 28, 1635 9.Ruth (No mention of Agnes or Temperance) See: https://archive.org/stream/baldwingenealogy00bald#page/41/mode/1up AND https://archive.org/stream/baldwingenealogy1889bald#page/992/mode/1up/search/sylvester

posted by Katie Pyle
Bryan-2855 and Bryan-33 appear to represent the same person because: data the same, except birthdate
posted by Daniel Postellon

Featured Asian and Pacific Islander connections: Sarah is 22 degrees from 今上 天皇, 16 degrees from Adrienne Clarkson, 20 degrees from Dwight Heine, 19 degrees from Dwayne Johnson, 17 degrees from Tupua Tamasese Lealofioaana, 17 degrees from Stacey Milbern, 16 degrees from Sono Osato, 30 degrees from 乾隆 愛新覺羅, 20 degrees from Ravi Shankar, 23 degrees from Taika Waititi, 21 degrees from Penny Wong and 14 degrees from Chang Bunker on our single family tree. Login to see how you relate to 33 million family members.

B  >  Bryan  |  A  >  Astwood  >  Sarah (Bryan) Astwood

Categories: Puritan Great Migration